Plausible vs Umami: Which Privacy Analytics Tool Fits a Small Site?
Pick Umami if you want to pay nothing: its cloud Hobby plan is free for one site and 100K events a month, and the self-hosted version is free under the MIT license. Pick Plausible if you're fine paying from $9 a month for an official WordPress plugin, a more finished product and three years of data retention. Neither tool uses cookies. The comparison below uses each vendor's own pages, checked on October 17, 2026.

The short version
| Plausible | Umami | |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest cloud plan | Starter, $9/month (10k pageviews, 1 site) | Hobby, $0 (100K events, 1 site) |
| Free trial | 30 days, no card | Not needed for Hobby |
| Data retention, entry plan | 3 years (Starter) | 6 months (Hobby) |
| Self-hosted version | Community Edition, AGPLv3 | Full app, MIT license |
| Cookies | None | None |
| WordPress plugin | Official, by Plausible | Third-party ("Integrate Umami") |
Prices come from the Plausible pricing section and the Umami pricing page. Both can change, so check them again before you pay.
Pricing: pageviews vs events
The two vendors count different things, which matters more than the headline price.
Plausible prices by monthly pageviews. At the 10k tier, the pricing section lists Starter at $9 a month for one site with 3 years of retention, Growth at $14 for up to 3 sites, and Business at $19 for up to 10 sites with 5 years of retention. Yearly billing is advertised as "2 months free," and every plan starts with a 30-day trial that doesn't ask for a card.
Umami prices by events, and a pageview is one event. Custom events (a button click, a form submit) count too. The pricing page lists:
- Hobby: $0, 100K events a month, 1 website, 6 months of data.
- Pro: $20 a month, 1 million events, up to 20 websites, 2 years of data.
- Business: $200 a month, 10 million events, unlimited websites, 5 years of data.
So for one small blog, Umami's free plan covers a lot of traffic, but it forgets everything older than six months. If you want to compare this November with last November, that's a real limit. Plausible's cheapest plan keeps three years.
Privacy and cookie banners
Both tools are built to avoid cookies. Plausible's data policy says it does not use "cookies, browser cache or local storage." It counts unique visitors with a hash of a daily salt, the site domain, the IP address and the browser's user agent. The salt is deleted every 24 hours, and raw IPs aren't stored. Umami's FAQ says it "does not use any cookies in the tracking code" and that it doesn't collect personally identifiable information.
Both vendors say their script alone doesn't need a cookie notice. That's their claim, not legal advice. Whether your site needs a banner also depends on everything else you load: ads, embedded videos, a newsletter pop-up. Swapping Google Analytics for either tool removes one reason for a banner, not necessarily all of them.
Self-hosting: where the two really differ
Umami self-hosted is the whole product. The Umami repository is MIT-licensed and needs a server with Node.js 18.18+ and PostgreSQL 12.14+. The cloud version adds email reports and a streaming API, according to the pricing page. Otherwise you get the same dashboard on your own server.
Plausible Community Edition is a deliberately trimmed version. Plausible's self-hosting page says CE is AGPLv3, is "published twice per year" while the cloud updates several times a week, and leaves out marketing funnels, ecommerce revenue goals, SSO and the Sites API. Bot filtering in CE is described as basic, while the cloud also excludes data center IPs. Support is community-only.
For a blogger, the practical question is whether you already run a small server. If you do, self-hosted Umami costs you nothing extra and has no feature gap that matters for a blog. If you don't, the time to set up and update a server is worth more than $9 a month.
WordPress: plugin quality
This is where Plausible wins for non-technical owners. The official Plausible plugin is published by Plausible Insights, showed 10,000+ active installations and an update in October 2026 when we checked, and can track events, campaigns and WooCommerce revenue. Its changelog says it also works with self-hosted CE.
Umami has no official plugin. The community plugin Integrate Umami asks for your website ID and script URL and needs WordPress 6.0+ and PHP 7.4+. It works, but you depend on a volunteer maintainer. You can also skip plugins and paste Umami's one-line script into your theme header.
Worked example (illustrative)
Illustrative example, not a real client. A WordPress recipe blog gets about 8,000 pageviews a month, uses Google Analytics, and has a cookie banner mainly because of GA.
- Before: GA4 reports the owner rarely opens, a banner many visitors decline, and gaps in the data from people who said no.
- Option A, Umami Hobby: $0. 8,000 pageviews plus a few hundred custom events fits well under 100K events. Downside: data older than six months disappears, so a yearly comparison is impossible.
- Option B, Plausible Starter: $9 a month (less on yearly billing), the official plugin, three years of history.
For this blog, we'd start on Umami Hobby and move to Plausible (or Umami Pro) once the owner actually starts comparing seasons. That way you pay only after you've shown yourself you'll use the reports.
Which one should you pick?
- Free and done: Umami Cloud Hobby, if one site and six months of history are enough.
- Free and you run a VPS: self-hosted Umami.
- WordPress, no tinkering, long history: Plausible Starter with the official plugin.
- Several small sites on one bill: compare Plausible Growth or Business with Umami Pro (up to 20 sites).
- You need funnels or revenue goals: Plausible Cloud, since CE doesn't include them.
Still on Google Analytics and unsure whether to leave? Our GA4 guide for bloggers covers the reports worth keeping, and tracking AI traffic in GA4 shows a setup neither privacy tool replicates exactly.
What neither tool tells you
Plausible and Umami only measure your own site. They can't tell you how big a competitor is, or whether a site you're about to partner with has real traffic. For that, see our guide to checking any site's traffic for free. If an advertiser asks for proof of your numbers, both tools can share a public dashboard link, which we cover in how to prove website traffic.
Want to know how your site looks from the outside? Run Satelo's free check: a 0–100 Quality Score from mostly open data (domain age, Tranco rank, Common Crawl presence, page speed), with the evidence behind each number, in about 30 seconds and with no signup.
FAQ
Is Umami really free?
Yes, in two ways. Umami Cloud's Hobby plan is $0 for one website and 100K events a month with 6 months of data retention, and the self-hosted version is free under the MIT license if you run your own server with Node.js and PostgreSQL.
Does Plausible have a free plan?
No permanent free cloud plan. Plausible offers a 30-day trial with no card, and the self-hosted Community Edition is free under AGPLv3, but it lacks funnels, ecommerce revenue goals, SSO and the Sites API.
Do Plausible or Umami need a cookie banner?
Both vendors say their tracking scripts set no cookies and don't need a cookie notice. Your site may still need a banner because of other things you load, such as ads or embedded videos, and the rules depend on your jurisdiction.
What is the difference between pageviews and events?
Plausible prices by pageviews. Umami prices by events, where each pageview is one event and each custom event, like a button click, is another. A site with many tracked clicks uses up an Umami allowance faster than its pageview count suggests.
Which is better for WordPress?
Plausible, for most owners: it has an official plugin from the company with event and WooCommerce tracking. Umami relies on a community plugin, Integrate Umami, or a script pasted into your theme.
Which one keeps data longer?
On entry plans, Plausible: Starter keeps 3 years and Business 5 years. Umami Cloud keeps 6 months on Hobby, 2 years on Pro and 5 years on Business. Self-hosted, both keep data as long as your own database does.
Is Umami's 6-month retention a problem?
Only if you want year-over-year comparisons. For a new blog checking which posts work this month, six months is enough. Once you care about seasonality, move to a plan with longer retention or self-host.
Can I run both at the same time?
Yes. Both are small scripts, so you can run them in parallel for a month, compare the numbers and the dashboards, then keep the one you actually open.
Read next




Check your site's Quality Score
Free, no sign-up: a 0–100 score from mostly open data. Then add your site to Satelo and get partner articles from sites of your level.
Enter a domain like example.com
Add my site